Celebrate the Heart of Country, Americana, and Roots Music!

Drop Us A Line, Y'all

Y'all interested in advertising, partnering up, contributing stories, joining our team, or just got a question? Well, don't be shy, drop us a line!

Follow Us

From “Dumbest Idea Ever” to Billion Dollar Empire: How Kelly Clarkson Inadvertently Caused the Rise of Taylor’s Version

Kelly Clarkson’s Suggestion That Revolutionized Taylor Swift's Career
by
  • Riley is a Senior Country Music Journalist for Country Thang Daily, known for her engaging storytelling and insightful coverage of the genre.
  • Before joining Country Thang Daily, Riley developed her expertise at Billboard and People magazine, focusing on feature stories and music reviews.
  • Riley has a Bachelor of Arts in Journalism from Belmont University, with a minor in Cultural Studies.

“@taylorswift13 just a thought, U should go in & re-record all the songs that U don’t own the masters on exactly how U did them but put brand new art & some kind of incentive so fans will no longer buy the old versions. I’d buy all of the new versions just to prove a point,” Kelly Clarkson tweeted amidst fellow singer Taylor Swift’s battle with Scooter Braun over her masters. Many thought it was “the dumbest idea ever.” But with the success of (Taylor’s Version), it’s reached legendary status. As fans said, it aged like fine wine. 

Rewind: Swift vs. Braun

2019 was a tough year for Swift, with Scooter Braun purchasing her former record label, Big Machine, along with the masters of her first six studio albums. And that wasn’t even the worst part. She only learned about it at the same time the whole world did. She tried to purchase it herself for years, as stated in her Tumblr post, but she was given unfavorable conditions. 

She wrote, “I was given an opportunity to sign back up to Big Machine Records and ‘earn’ one album back at a time, one for every new one I turned in. I walked away because I knew once I signed that contract, Scott Borchetta would sell the label, thereby selling me and my future.”

Did Kelly Clarkson give Taylor Swift the idea to re-record her music?

In the midst of the heated battle, Clarkson gave Swift sage advice and a lifeline. She suggested through X (formerly called Twitter) that she should re-record her albums. Fans saw this as a brilliant business move, but some questioned the need for it. 

While some flat-out thought it was “the dumbest idea ever.” 

But for the most part, people were skeptical, though it wouldn’t be unprecedented for an artist to go down that path. 

Skepticism: Can Taylor Swift Really Re-Record Her Old Songs?

Following Clarkson’s tweet, debates and discussions about whether Swift could really re-record her old songs flooded the Internet and social media. After all, she wouldn’t be the first. In an article published by Variety, they cited the ‘80s rock band Def Leppard, who refused to allow Universal Music to use any of their original recordings for anything other than physical products. 

Music legal experts thought it was worth a try, but they doubted that Taylor could do it right away due to common “re-recording restrictions,” which typically run from two to three years after the agreement or five years after releasing the track. JoJo also went through a similar situation, and she fought for seven years to earn back her albums. 

Behind The Revolutionizing Idea

In her appearance on the special Sunday edition of The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon a few months after her tweet went viral, the American Idol alum revealed that she actually got the idea from her then-mother-in-law, Reba McEntire. She shared that it was exactly what McEntire did to own her masters. Taylor was an artist who had been writing songs since she was a little girl, so she understood why it was vital for her to get complete ownership of her work. 

In an interview with SXM in June 2023, Clarkson shared that she didn’t know much about Swift’s situation when she tweeted her career-revolutionizing suggestion. She said that all she heard was the fact that the singer wanted to own the songs she had written. That was it. And even if she hadn’t said it, Clarkson believed Swift would’ve come up with that on her own – maybe she already knew about it way before she posted the tweet. 

What is the Difference Between Fearless and Taylor’s Version?

A month after Clarkson made the suggestion, despite widespread skepticism, Swift announced her intention to rerecord her first six albums. Two years later, she dropped her first: Fearless (Taylor’s Version). 

Talking with PEOPLE, she outlined the process behind her re-recording her project. Production-wise, she wanted to stay loyal to the original melodies. But if there was anything they felt they could improve upon the sonic quality, they did. That is, they went in with a mindset to create “the same but better” version. As for the vocals, she was very detailed, going through the songs line by line. 

But it wouldn’t be Swift if it didn’t come with a twist. For Taylor’s Version, she gifted fans with never-before-released tracks, which she called “From the Vault.” These were the ones that were cut from the album at the time. She then followed with Red TV in the same year. And then, in 2023, she released Speak Now TV and 1989 TV. 

Overturning Skepticism: The Success Story

RELATED: Top 15 Taylor Swift Country Hits: Our Favorites from Her Catalog

It wouldn’t be an overstatement to say that Swift dominated the music scene when she released her first re-record. And it only got bigger from there. In fact, 1989 TV sold 1.65 million copies in its first week, outselling the first week of the original 1989. Take note, she isn’t even done yet. She still has two left: her self-titled debut album and, of course, Reputation.  

Kelcie Schofield, a 2023 graduate from the University of Virginia’s Darden School of Business who wrote a case study on the sale of Swift’s masters, said that people expected it to be huge. But no one would’ve predicted it would be this massive. “It’s not like she’s the first person to ever do this. But she’s the first person to make it a phenomenon.” 

Her re-recorded albums inspired Swift’s biggest tour yet: The Eras Tour. As of December 2023, her career-spanning tour sold over 4.3 million tickets, crossing the billion-dollar mark. And it’s projected that 2024 would make her another billion in sales. 

Nevertheless, Swift’s feet are rooted on the ground. And in every release of her project, she would send flowers to Clarkson as a thank-you, along with a gift particular to that album. The most recent was a cardigan in honor of 1989 TV. 

From Skepticism to Success

The indelible success of Swift’s re-recordings is a double-edged sword. While it empowered artists, it also prompted record labels to put clauses in place to make sure it would never happen again. But the positive still outweighed the negative, as Atty. Gandhar Savur noted that there was only so much that the companies could do to prevent it. “Artist representatives are going to push back against that, and a certain standard is ingrained in our industry that is not easy to move away from.”

To Kelly Clarkson, it was a harmless suggestion. All she wanted to do was extend help to a fellow singer who wanted and deserved to own her life’s work. To Swift, it was a passion project to reclaim the music she had worked so hard for despite the skepticism. Now, “the dumbest idea ever” ended up becoming the biggest and most empowering thing they both had ever done. 

Latest Stories

Jon Batiste performs a jazz-infused rendition of the national anthem at Super Bowl LIX in New Orleans, honoring his Louisiana roots.

Jon Batiste Delivers Unique Super Bowl National Anthem Performance

Jon Batiste delivered a uniquely soulful rendition of “The Star-Spangled Banner” at Super Bowl LIX, infusing the national anthem with the unmistakable spirit of his Louisiana roots. The seven-time Grammy ...

2025 CMT Music Awards Cancelled

Why Were the 2025 CMT Music Awards Canceled? The Truth Revealed

Country music fans will have to mark a different night on their calendars this year. The 2025 CMT Music Awards have been officially canceled, leaving many wondering what led to ...

Darius Rucker announces he's now living in London, sparking curiosity among fans about whether the move is permanent and the reasons behind his life change.

Darius Rucker Reveals He’s No Longer Living in the U.S.

Darius Rucker and the American South go hand in hand. Whether it’s Hootie & The Blowfish’s “Cracked Rear View” playing at a summer cookout or “Wagon Wheel” blasting from the ...

Country singer Andrew Millsaps shares how his fiancée ended their engagement via text before a show, inspiring him to channel the heartbreak into new music.

Country Singer Andrew Millsaps Got Dumped in the Worst Way Possible—Right Before a Show

Breakups are never easy, but some are downright brutal. For country singer Andrew Millsaps, the heartbreak hit at the worst possible time—while he was on stage. The Neon Union vocalist ...

Rascal Flatts and the Jonas Brothers collaborate on 'I Dare You,' a powerful heartbreak anthem, ahead of Rascal Flatts' 25th Anniversary Life Is a Highway Tour.

Rascal Flatts and Jonas Brothers Collaborate on New Song “I Dare You”

Rascal Flatts may have built their legacy on heartfelt country anthems. Still, their latest collaboration proves they’re not afraid to shake things up. The iconic trio has teamed up with ...

Cody Johnson opens up about learning to be romantic with his wife, Brandi, after 15 years of marriage, emphasizing the importance of simple gestures.

Cody Johnson Shares How He Learned to Be Romantic With His Wife Brandi

Cody Johnson might be a country music powerhouse, but he’s just a husband trying to get it right at home. Married to his wife, Brandi, since 2008, Johnson has spent ...

Luke Bryan Says Beyonce Is The Greatest Singer Of All Time

Luke Bryan Just Called Beyoncé “The Greatest Singer of Our Lifetime”

Luke Bryan poured gasoline on an already blazing fire by calling Beyoncé “the greatest singer in our lifetime.” As Cowboy Carter continues to divide country music fans, Bryan’s comments feel ...

At the 2025 Grammy Awards, Beyoncé, dressed in a champagne-colored gown, sits wide-eyed and open-mouthed in her seat, displaying visible shock as Taylor Swift announces her as the winner for Best Country Album. In the background, Kacey Musgraves, wearing a white tank top, claps with a neutral expression, her face showing no visible emotion.

The Real Reason Beyoncé Won a Grammy for Best Country Album

Beyoncé’s Cowboy Carter winning Best Country Album at the 2025 Grammys was never about the music. It was about power, control, and pushing an agenda unrelated to country music. The ...

Whoopi Goldberg passionately defends Beyoncé's Grammy win for Best Country Album on 'The View.' Seated at the show's panel, Goldberg gestures emphatically, her expression animated as she addresses the camera. She wears a patterned blouse and round glasses, conveying determination. Co-hosts listen attentively, and the studio backdrop features 'The View' logo. Goldberg's body language underscores her firm stance against critics of Beyoncé's achievement.

Whoopi Goldberg Sides With Beyoncé’s Country Grammy Win and Tells Critics to “Sit Down”

Whoopi Goldberg has a long history of running her mouth without understanding the issue. Still, this time, she’s stomping all over country music like it’s just another Hollywood punchline. On ...

Wynonna Judd raising her granddaughter Kaliyah as her daughter Grace Kelley navigates ongoing legal challenges.

Wynonna Judd Reveals She’s Raising Her Granddaughter After Daughter’s Legal Troubles

In two weeks, Wynonna Judd’s world changed forever. She lost her mother. She became a grandmother. And somewhere in the middle of grief and joy, she stepped into a role ...