Carrie Underwood knows a thing or two about American Idol pressure, but some viewers think she brought the wrong kind of heat this week. After Sunday and Monday’s Top 5 shows, Underwood is catching serious backlash online for her critique of contestant Jamal Roberts, who many felt delivered one of the most compelling performances of the night.
Jamal, a 27-year-old powerhouse vocalist, took on the Marvin Gaye and Tammi Terrell classic “Ain’t No Mountain High Enough” in front of a live audience and a judging panel that included Underwood, Luke Bryan, and Lionel Richie. The crowd ate it up. The other two judges were on their feet. Luke Bryan called it well-deserved and praised Jamal’s stage presence. Lionel Richie went as far as to say Jamal “Jamalerized” the song, a nod to his ability to transform classics into something uniquely his own.
Carrie? She stayed seated.
And then came the critique. “I feel like you missed such an opportunity to move around and entertain,” she told him, even as the crowd was still buzzing from his performance. “Pull us in not just with your voice, but everything else going on.” It was the kind of comment that might’ve landed differently earlier in the season. However, with Roberts now the last Black contestant remaining, and after a performance that clearly connected with both the live audience and viewers at home, the timing raised eyebrows.
RELATED: Jamal Roberts Just Gave Carrie Underwood’s “Undo It” the Redemption It Needed
Even worse, she seemed to go silent after Jamal’s second performance, a soaring, soul-stirring rendition of “Beauty and the Beast” that once again brought the house down. Underwood turned to her fellow judges and offered no commentary at all. Fans noticed.
For You
Within minutes, social media lit up. Viewers accused Carrie of holding Jamal to a different standard than the other contestants, many of whom also stood relatively still during their performances without receiving the same critique. One user wrote, “Carrie telling Jamal to move around when everyone else is standing still? Come on.” Another added, “The hate was written on her face the moment he stepped on stage.”
And this wasn’t a small ripple either. Twitter (now X) was flooded with the kind of fan backlash that Idol hasn’t seen since its earlier seasons. Several fans even hoped Underwood wouldn’t return as a judge next season if this was how she planned to treat contestants. Whether that’s a stretch or not, the sentiment was loud and clear.
RELATED: Jamal Roberts Brings Church and Southern Soul to Stapleton’s “Tennessee Whiskey” on “Idol”
Now, to be fair, it’s not out of bounds for a judge to push a contestant to step it up in the final rounds. It’s part of the job. But fans expect consistency. And when the comments land off-key, especially when the performance in question earns a standing ovation from everyone else, it opens the door for criticism, deserved or not.
As for Jamal Roberts, he’s through to the Top 3. He showed once again why he’s one of the most dynamic vocalists left in the competition, and the controversy surrounding the moment might’ve only galvanized his supporters heading into the finale.
Carrie Underwood hasn’t responded to the online reaction, but one thing is certain: when the lights go up on next week’s final episode, all eyes will be on Jamal and plenty will still be watching to see what Carrie says next.
