In June 2005, two weeks after she won American Idol, Carrie Underwood made her Grand Ole Opry debut.
After her set, she stood at the side of the stage, called the night kind of magical and then admitted how big the moment felt to her.
“I don’t feel like I deserve this at all,” she said.
She once told the Opry she always knew what it was, even if she could not say how. “You don’t have to see it or hear it, you automatically just know what it is. That’s how legendary it is.” The first country singer to win American Idol has spent the years since building a catalog that answers the doubt she felt that night.
Taste of Country has ranked the 50 best Carrie Underwood songs, keeping the list to songs with her as the primary vocalist, so it leaves out her collaborations with Brad Paisley and Keith Urban, “Remind Me” and “The Fighter.” The outlet counts her career at 15 No. 1 singles and 28 Billboard Country Airplay Top 10s.
Narrowing that catalog to 10 is hard for the most-awarded artist in CMT Music Awards history, so Country Thang Daily’s countdown follows its own order, with faith, family and the stories behind the songs counting most.
10. “Home Sweet Home”
Underwood won the fourth season of American Idol in 2005 as the first country singer the show ever crowned. Her cover of Motley Crue’s “Home Sweet Home” was later featured during the Season 9 finale of American Idol, and it landed on some deluxe versions of her album Play On.
A rock ballad became a country singer’s song, and it played on the same show where her own road began.
9. “Heartbeat”
“Heartbeat” came from Storyteller, and it is a gentle love song. Underwood performed it with Sam Hunt at the Grammys, giving one of the quietest songs in her catalog one of the biggest stages in music.
8. “Love Wins”
In 2019, “Love Wins” became the first single of her career that did not crack the Top 10. For an artist with 28 Country Airplay Top 10s, that was a rare mark next to her name.
The song itself is a message of hope, built on the belief that love outlasts whatever is pulling people apart.
7. “Wasted”
Underwood released four singles from Some Hearts, and “Wasted” was the last of them, according to Taste of Country.
It is about refusing to let the years slip away in regret, and it closed out the album’s run of singles in a way that suited a young singer making the most of her shot.
6. “Two Black Cadillacs”
“Two Black Cadillacs” came out as a single in 2012, and Taste of Country put it at No. 10 on its own list, calling the dark, murderous power ballad a song in a league of its own.
It takes the cheekiness out of a revenge song like the Chicks’ “Goodbye Earl,” and the outlet admitted that for a while there, they were a little afraid of her.
5. “Little Toy Guns”
“Little Toy Guns” was a Top 5 hit for Underwood. It has all but disappeared from country radio since, which makes it the most overlooked hit on this list.
The song shows how fighting between parents can hurt a child. A hit that tells a hard family truth from a child’s side deserves to be heard again.
4. “Church Bells”
“Church Bells” was the third single from Storyteller, and it has gone Double-Platinum.
Story songs about a woman settling the score are a country tradition, and few singers tell one better than the woman who named an album Storyteller.
3. “Before He Cheats”
Some Hearts, released in 2005, is the best-selling album from any American Idol contestant and the best-selling solo female debut album in country music history, and “Before He Cheats” helped carry it there.
A Louisville Slugger, a pair of headlights and a keyed four-wheel drive gave country music one of its most famous revenge songs, and it showed early on how famous a country singer from Idol could become.
2. “Cry Pretty”
“Cry Pretty” is the title song of her 2018 album, and it is about the moment a person’s feelings take over and there is no keeping the tears neat.
Underwood performed it at the 2018 ACM Awards after suffering several miscarriages and a facial injury from a fall, Taste of Country noted. She sang a song about tears that cannot be hidden after a stretch that hard, and of all the moments behind these 10 songs, that one asked the most of her.
1. “Jesus, Take the Wheel”
The song began with a story songwriter Gordie Sampson heard from his aunt, according to Craig Shelburne, author of 100 Years of Grand Ole Opry.
“As she recalled losing control of her car on an icy road, she told him, ‘I threw up my hands and I asked God to take control of the wheel.’”
Sampson wrote the song with Brett James and Hillary Lindsey, and Underwood released it in 2005. “Jesus, Take the Wheel” spent six weeks at No. 1, won two Grammys and took the ACM Award for Single of the Year. When the Opry turned 100 in 2025, it named the song to its list of the 100 Greatest Country Songs.
An aunt on an icy road let go and asked God to take over, and a young singer just out of American Idol carried that prayer to No. 1.
Shop Carrie Underwood
- Greatest Hits: Decade #1VinylWith “Before He Cheats” and “Jesus, Take the Wheel”See it on Amazon
- My GiftVinylHer Christmas albumSee it on Amazon
- Find Your PathBook · 2020Her guide to health, fitness and the Fit52 lifestyleSee it on Amazon
As an Amazon Associate, Country Thang Daily earns from qualifying purchases.
Less than three years after she said she did not deserve the Opry stage, Randy Travis invited Carrie Underwood to join the cast on March 15, 2008, and she answered, “Let me think about it.” When she joined, Bill Anderson introduced her and Garth Brooks inducted her. “The induction award they gave me says, ‘Hey, you’re a part of the family,'” she once told the Opry.
It took 50 songs to rank the best of Carrie Underwood, and these 10 show why the family made room for the girl who once said she did not deserve to be there.
Know someone who loves Carrie Underwood?
Pass this story along to your friends and family on Facebook.