Celebrate the Heart of Country, Americana, and Roots Music!

Drop Us A Line, Y'all

Y'all interested in advertising, partnering up, contributing stories, joining our team, or just got a question? Well, don't be shy, drop us a line!

Follow Us

Why Did Kelly Clarkson Sign an Autograph as Carrie Underwood?

by
  • Arden is a Senior Country Music Journalist for Country Thang Daily, specializing in classic hits and contemporary chart-toppers.
  • Prior to joining Country Thang Daily, Arden wrote for Billboard and People magazine, covering country music legends and emerging artists.
  • Arden holds a Bachelor of Arts in Journalism from the University of Tennessee, with a minor in Music Studies.

Sometimes, having to resort to a white lie is the better choice for some as it not only preserves the ego of the person in question, but it also helps people mitigate their gaps from one another.

One good example is when Kelly Clarkson once signed an autograph as Carrie Underwood to bail out a fan who has mistaken her identity for the latter. What’s worse is, the fans of these country stars are kind of in each other’s hot water right now.

Clarkson x Underwood Misunderstandings

The incident was once again dug up the Clarkson x Underwood fan rumble starting in 2004 when an Underwood fan mistook Clarkson as ‘Underwood.’ Like the usual gesture of admiration, the fan couldn’t help herself but to publicly call out ‘So Small’ which was Underwood’s single mistakenly addressing it to Clarkson. To save her the embarrassment, Kelly Clarkson, in her show, revealed that she had to do what’s best in the situation. That means she has to borrow Underwood’s identity for an autograph.

In her talk show, Clarkson pondered how she looked nothing like Underwood so it was still a mystery how the fan had mistaken her for the other. In the end, she just laughed it all away, but not without that guilty thought that she might have done something illegal.

No Need for Competition

Of course, there was really nothing between Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood. They both received their breaks in different seasons of American Idol, 2002, and 2005 respectively.

Probably due to some similarities, they’re often the targets of tabloid newspaper rumors that enrage their admirers. In 2018, both stars decided to end these disputes by having a photo together. That’s to debunk one of the nasty rumor suggesting that they could never locate the two in the same place in the Radio Disney Awards event. Kelly Clarkson highlighted that they didn’t even know each other that well for people to pit them with each other as enemies.

In the same year, they also exchanged tweets backing each other. Some followers asked who among them is the greatest American Idol winner of all-time. Trying to avoid sparks that time, Carrie Underwood simply replied that she wished that more publications would just celebrate a woman’s success without comparing them with each other, therefore clearing the misunderstanding between her and Kelly Clarkson’s fans.

Latest Stories

Reba McEntire with son Shelby Blackstock and daughter-in-law Marissa Branch smiling in festive overalls and chili-pepper necklaces at home, as Shelby opens up about the heartbreaking miscarriage of their long-awaited baby boy just months after losing Brandon Blackstock.

Reba McEntire’s Son, Shelby Blackstock, Says the Pregnancy Loss Left Him Heartbroken

Heartbreak hit home again for one of country music’s most beloved families. Shelby Blackstock, Reba McEntire’s only son, and his wife, Marissa, have opened up about a devastating loss that’s ...

Maddie & Tae, Madison Font and Taylor Kerr, pose together in matching boho style as the duo officially confirms their heartbreaking split after 15 years, with Tae focusing on family and Maddie launching solo while insisting their sister-like bond remains forever.

Maddie & Tae Confirm Heartbreaking Split After 15 Years and Say It’s Not the End of Their Bond

They built a whole world together, and now they are walking away from it with tears in their eyes and love still intact. After fifteen years of harmony, hits, and ...

Garth Brooks performs at the 2025 Kennedy Center Honors wearing his signature black cowboy hat and striped shirt, strumming a Takamine guitar while paying tribute to rock legends KISS instead of fellow country icon George Strait during the December 7 ceremony.

Garth Brooks Performed at the Kennedy Center Honors But Not for George Strait

You’d think if Garth Brooks walked into a room where George Strait was being honored, he’d be first in line to sing his praises. But that ain’t how it went ...

Reba McEntire with son Shelby Blackstock, daughter-in-law Marissa Branch, and husband Rex Linn in a family photo, as Marissa speaks out about the heartbreaking miscarriage of their baby boy just months after the death of Reba's former stepson Brandon Blackstock.

Reba McEntire’s Family Is Hit With More Heartbreak as Her Daughter-in-Law Speaks Out on Pregnancy Loss

Sometimes even the strongest families get knocked down more than once before they catch their breath. Reba McEntire‘s family has just lived through another heavy and painful chapter. Just four ...

President Donald Trump places the Kennedy Center Honors medal around George Strait's neck in the Oval Office, with the King of Country smiling in his signature black cowboy hat and tuxedo during the powerful 2025 ceremony honoring his legendary career.

President Trump Presents George Strait With Kennedy Center Medal in Powerful Oval Office Moment

The King of Country just got a medal from the President in the most cowboy way imaginable. George Strait walked into the Oval Office this past Saturday with the same ...

Miley Cyrus and Dolly Parton share the stage singing "Jolene," Miley in black and Dolly in glittering white, capturing the raw, emotional 2012 Backyard Sessions moment that proved Miley's country roots and earned praise as the greatest cover of Dolly's classic.

Dolly Parton’s Goddaughter Once Covered “Jolene” and Some Say It’s the Best Version Since the Original

When your godmother is Dolly Parton, there are certain songs you do not just cover, you carry them. And when Miley Cyrus tackled “Jolene” during her now-legendary Backyard Sessions, she ...

Kelly Clarkson gestures emphatically during an interview, revealing she forfeited songwriting royalties worth hundreds of thousands (or millions) on "My Life Would Suck Without You" rather than share official credit with producer Dr. Luke.

Kelly Clarkson Gave Up Songwriting Royalties to Avoid Being Tied to a Producer She Couldn’t Stand

Some songs pay the bills, but not all are worth the price. Kelly Clarkson’s 2009 hit “My Life Would Suck Without You” was a massive success. It shot from No. ...

Gavin Adcock performing live on stage in a white cowboy hat, sunglasses, and patterned western shirt, holding a mic in one hand and a Miller Lite in the other, revealing that Alan Jackson's "Remember When" is the one country song that still brings him to tears every time.

Gavin Adcock Says One Alan Jackson Song Still Wrecks Him Every Time and It Ain’t Even Close

Gavin Adcock might look like he is built for brawls and bar fights, but even the rowdiest country wild card has a soft spot that can split him wide open. ...

Post Malone grinning with full beard and tattoos while strumming a yellow Martin acoustic guitar on stage in a brown suede jacket and bolo tie, and will headline the free Bud Light Presents Post Malone & Buddies concert on February 6, 2026, at Fort Mason in San Francisco during Super Bowl LX weekend.

The Super Bowl Just Got a Whole Lot More Country With Post Malone Headlining Bud Light’s Concert

Country is officially in the Super Bowl conversation now and it is Post Malone leading the charge with a mic in one hand and a cold Bud Light in the ...

Kelly Clarkson delivers a jaw-dropping Kellyoke performance of Ella Langley's "Weren't For The Wind" on The Kelly Clarkson Show, eyes closed and pouring raw emotion into the mic while wearing a denim shirt, sparking massive fan demands for her long-awaited country album in 2025.

Kelly Clarkson Dropped the Most Insane Ella Langley Cover and Now Everyone Is Begging for Her Country Album

Kelly Clarkson just covered an Ella Langley song on national TV, and now half the country fanbase is wondering why the hell she hasn’t dropped a country record already. It ...