Celebrate the Heart of Country, Americana, and Roots Music!

Drop Us A Line, Y'all

Y'all interested in advertising, partnering up, contributing stories, joining our team, or just got a question? Well, don't be shy, drop us a line!

Follow Us

Why Did Kelly Clarkson Sign an Autograph as Carrie Underwood?

by
  • Arden is a Senior Country Music Journalist for Country Thang Daily, specializing in classic hits and contemporary chart-toppers.
  • Prior to joining Country Thang Daily, Arden wrote for Billboard and People magazine, covering country music legends and emerging artists.
  • Arden holds a Bachelor of Arts in Journalism from the University of Tennessee, with a minor in Music Studies.

Sometimes, having to resort to a white lie is the better choice for some as it not only preserves the ego of the person in question, but it also helps people mitigate their gaps from one another.

One good example is when Kelly Clarkson once signed an autograph as Carrie Underwood to bail out a fan who has mistaken her identity for the latter. What’s worse is, the fans of these country stars are kind of in each other’s hot water right now.

Clarkson x Underwood Misunderstandings

The incident was once again dug up the Clarkson x Underwood fan rumble starting in 2004 when an Underwood fan mistook Clarkson as ‘Underwood.’ Like the usual gesture of admiration, the fan couldn’t help herself but to publicly call out ‘So Small’ which was Underwood’s single mistakenly addressing it to Clarkson. To save her the embarrassment, Kelly Clarkson, in her show, revealed that she had to do what’s best in the situation. That means she has to borrow Underwood’s identity for an autograph.

In her talk show, Clarkson pondered how she looked nothing like Underwood so it was still a mystery how the fan had mistaken her for the other. In the end, she just laughed it all away, but not without that guilty thought that she might have done something illegal.

No Need for Competition

Of course, there was really nothing between Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood. They both received their breaks in different seasons of American Idol, 2002, and 2005 respectively.

Probably due to some similarities, they’re often the targets of tabloid newspaper rumors that enrage their admirers. In 2018, both stars decided to end these disputes by having a photo together. That’s to debunk one of the nasty rumor suggesting that they could never locate the two in the same place in the Radio Disney Awards event. Kelly Clarkson highlighted that they didn’t even know each other that well for people to pit them with each other as enemies.

In the same year, they also exchanged tweets backing each other. Some followers asked who among them is the greatest American Idol winner of all-time. Trying to avoid sparks that time, Carrie Underwood simply replied that she wished that more publications would just celebrate a woman’s success without comparing them with each other, therefore clearing the misunderstanding between her and Kelly Clarkson’s fans.

Trending

Latest Stories

Young Oaklynn Rae Domer, 3-year-old daughter of WPRA champion Kelsie Domer, smiles atop brown horse in saddle at rodeo arena with hills behind, days before tragic February 19, 2026 accident sparks widespread pink tributes in mourning.

Pink Tributes Flood the Arena as Rodeo Community Grieves Oaklynn Rae Domer

A sea of pink has filled rodeo arenas across the country as the community mourns the heartbreaking loss of three-year-old Oaklynn Rae Domer. The rodeo world continues to grieve following ...

Kelsie Domer, WPRA champion breakaway roper, poses with husband and toddler daughter Oaklynn Rae Domer holding championship buckles and plaques at rodeo arena, days before tragic horse accident claims 3-year-old's life on February 19, 2026.

Rodeo World Mourns 3-Year-Old Oaklynn Rae Domer After Tragic Horse Accident

3-year-old Oaklynn Rae Domer, daughter of WPRCA champion Kelsie Domer, dies in a freak horse accident, but the rodeo world honors her with pink tributes. The rodeo world is grieving ...

Brianna Chickenfry speaks on Impaulsive podcast in tan suede jacket, revealing Zach Bryan's $12M NDA terms banning social media and work for 5 years, while slamming his 2025 wedding as a dig at her.

Brianna Chickenfry Reveals What Was in Zach Bryan’s $12M NDA as She Slams His Wedding

Brianna Chickenfry is shedding new light on the $12 million NDA she says ex Zach Bryan asked her to sign, while also taking fresh shots at his recent wedding. During ...

Bunnie XO and Jelly Roll walk arm-in-arm at event, Bunnie in white dress and bold makeup, Jelly Roll in black vest with "Bunny" patch, tattoos visible, as they embrace faith as "baby Christians" after rediscovering God.

Bunnie XO Calls Herself and Jelly Roll “Baby Christians” After Finding God Again

Bunnie XO says she and Jelly Roll are “baby Christians” learning to walk in faith together after finding their way back to God. The Dumb Blonde podcast host, whose real ...

Riley Green makes acting debut as former Navy SEAL Garrett in Yellowstone spinoff Marshals, standing with brown horse by rustic barn in cowboy hat, denim jacket, and mustache in official promo image ahead of March 1 premiere.

Riley Green Confirmed for Role in ‘Yellowstone’ Universe Series ‘Marshals’

Riley Green is officially saddling up for a ride into the Yellowstone universe. After weeks of fan speculation and a trailer moment that sent social media into overdrive, it has ...

Kid Rock performs energetically on stage in black leather jacket, feathered black hat, aviator sunglasses, and rings, microphone in hand during Freedom 250 Tour, defending $5,000 front-row ticket prices for premium proximity.

Kid Rock Charging $5,000 for Front Row Seats on Freedom 250 Tour

Kid Rock’s Freedom 250 Tour is drawing attention not just for the music, but for the price of its front-row seats. The rocker is selling “First Class Seats” for $5,000 ...

Luke Combs and wife Nicole smile with newborn son Chet Wiley Combs in cozy family portrait, big brothers Tex and Beau gazing at baby brother on window seat, celebrating arrival of third boy announced February 19, 2026.

It’s a Boy Again! Luke Combs and Nicole Welcome Baby No. 3

The Combs family just got a little bigger and a lot sweeter. Luke Combs and his wife, Nicole, have welcomed their third child, another baby boy, officially making them a ...

Brianna Chickenfry and Samantha Leonard side-by-side comparison in split image, highlighting uncanny resemblance with dark hair, similar facial features, and intense gazes amid claims Zach Bryan's marriage was a dig at his ex.

Brianna Chickenfry Says Zach Bryan’s Marriage Was “All a Dig at Me”

The post-breakup drama between Brianna Chickenfry and Zach Bryan is not slowing down. During a February 17 appearance on the Impaulsive podcast with Logan Paul and Mike Majlak, Brianna LaPaglia, ...

Trace Adkins performs live on stage in black pinstripe suit and cowboy hat, microphone in hand under colorful lights, hinting 2026 30th Anniversary Tour may be his final road run at age 64.

Trace Adkins Hints 2026 Tour May Be His Final Run on the Road

Trace Adkins is leaving the door open for 2026 to be his final year on the road. The country veteran recently sparked retirement speculation after hinting that his current 30th ...

Riley Green and Ella Langley smile together in golf cart at event, Riley in white Texas Rangers jersey and cowboy hat, Ella in white top holding red cup, celebrating her "Choosin' Texas" No. 1 chart success and Alabama roots.

Riley Green Applauds Ella Langley’s Chart Dominance and Alabama Roots

Riley Green is tipping his hat to one of his own. As Ella Langley celebrates making history with “Choosin’ Texas,” fellow Alabama native Riley Green is making it clear he ...