Sometime around two or three o’clock in the morning, Narvel Blackstock came back to a San Diego hotel room from a meeting with their pilot and told Reba McEntire that one of the planes had crashed.
She told Oprah Winfrey in 2012 how the rest of that conversation went.
“…I said, ‘Are they OK?’ He said, ‘I don’t think so.’ I said, ‘But you’re not sure?’ He said, ‘I don’t think so.'”
It was March 16, 1991. Her band had played a private show in San Diego, and two planes waited at Brown Field to fly the group on to its next concert in Fort Wayne, Ind. Minutes after takeoff, the chartered jet carrying her band and crew crashed into Otay Mountain, killing all 10 people aboard. The second plane arrived safely.
Reba McEntire was not on the plane. She, her then-husband and manager Narvel, and stylist Sandi Spika had stayed overnight in San Diego. Before that year was out, she released an album called For My Broken Heart and dedicated it to the people she lost.
How Many Members of Reba McEntire’s Band Died in the Plane Crash?
Eight members of Reba McEntire’s band and crew died in the crash, seven band members and her tour manager, along with the pilot and co-pilot. They were tour manager Jim Hammon, keyboardist and bandleader Kirk Cappello, keyboardist Joey Cigainero, drummer Tony Saputo, guitarists Michael Thomas and Chris Austin, bassist Terry Jackson and backup singer Paula Kaye Evans.
McEntire later described what happened in that 2012 interview with Oprah. The tip of the plane’s wing hit a rock on the side of Otay Mountain, she said, and it killed everyone aboard.
The pilots were flying at night out of an unfamiliar airport over mountainous terrain under visual flight rules, and the captain had called flight service three times before takeoff to say he did not have the instrument departure procedure. The National Transportation Safety Board blamed the pilot and co-pilot, and to a lesser extent an FAA flight service specialist whose instructions never mentioned the mountainous terrain.
Reba McEntire Sang at the Oscars Nine Days Later, and Her Friends Helped Her Back Onstage
Nine days after the crash, on March 25, McEntire was scheduled to sing the Oscar-nominated “I’m Checkin’ Out” at the Academy Awards. She had said yes before the crash happened, and she later told Country Now that she almost did not do it.
She sang it as planned, and she has explained what changed her mind.
“I went ahead and sang the song because I felt Jim Hammon talking to me saying, ‘Go do it for us. We’re checked out of this heartbreak hotel,’” she has said.
In 2022, she returned to the Oscars with another Diane Warren song, “Somehow You Do,” one she said gives hope, and she told the story again. When she felt a heaviness in her heart before that show, she told Country Now, she gave it up to God, and it lifted like a hundred pounds.
She told Garden & Gun that getting back onstage was really hard, and she told the magazine who called.
“…Vince Gill called and said, ‘Buddy, I’ll be there for you.’ Dolly Parton said, ‘Here, take my band.’ It was such a gift to see how many people stepped forward to help, and to reassure, because so many of us had hearts that were broken.”
Dolly also lent her bandleader, Gary Smith, who used his contacts to pull together a new group.
For My Broken Heart Became the Best-Selling Album of Reba McEntire’s Career
She released For My Broken Heart on Oct. 1, 1991, as a tribute to the band and crew she lost, and in the liner notes she called it “a form of healing for all our broken hearts.” She co-wrote just one of its songs, “Bobby.”
The title track, written by Liz Hengber and Keith Palmer and released the day before the album, went to No. 1 on country radio, and so did “Is There Life Out There.” “The Greatest Man I Never Knew” was among its hits too.
The album peaked at No. 13 on the Billboard 200, her highest there at the time, and it remains the best-selling album of her career, certified quadruple platinum with four million copies sold. Accepting ACM Top Female Vocalist and Video of the Year in 1992, she spoke of “my eight buddies.”
She told Oprah in 2012 how the years have felt.
“I don’t guess it ever quits hurting.”
In November 2015, she took a helicopter up to the crash site, and on the 25th anniversary she wrote that she felt in her heart they knew how much they were still missed.
On March 16, 2026, 35 years to the day, she said in a statement that her band and crew were dear friends who shared the road with her, and she honored them with a gift to MusiCares, an organization that takes care of the people who take care of the music.
Thirty-five years after the crash on Otay Mountain, the woman who made For My Broken Heart was still honoring the eight friends she lost there.
Know someone who loves Reba McEntire?
Pass this story along to your friends and family on Facebook.