Celebrate the Heart of Country, Americana, and Roots Music!

Patsy Cline Hated Willie Nelson’s ‘Crazy,’ Then Recorded It on Crutches and Made It Her Signature Song

Patsy Cline is shown with Willie Nelson inset as she first disliked his song “Crazy,” then recorded it on crutches and turned it into her signature track.
Riley Johnson
by

Riley Johnson covers country music’s legends, tributes, and the stories behind the songs for Country Thang Daily. When a legend is honored, remembered, or back in the spotlight, Riley is usually the one writing it.

Get Country Thang Daily first on GoogleGet CTD first on GoogleAdd us as a preferred source in Top StoriesAdd us as a preferred sourceAdd

About two months after she went through a windshield, Patsy Cline was on crutches, with broken ribs that had not healed, recording a song in a Nashville studio that she did not even like.

When she heard the writer’s own offbeat demo, she said so plainly, as Gordon Stoker of the Jordanaires later recalled to NPR.

“Look, Hoss, there ain’t no way I could sing it like that guy’s a-singing it.”

That guy was Willie Nelson, and the song was “Crazy.” It was released on Oct. 16, 1961, and it became Cline’s biggest hit and one of her signature songs.

Patsy Cline Did Not Want ‘Crazy,’ and She Had Hated a Hit Before

Nelson was a struggling songwriter when he wrote it, and he first called it “St𝐮pid.”

The song found its way to Patsy Cline from two directions. Hank Cochran, who co-wrote her hit “I Fall to Pieces,” pitched it to Owen Bradley, who loved it despite Nelson’s offbeat demo. Her husband, Charlie Dick, got Nelson’s recording at a bar and brought it home to her.

She initially hated it, and it was not her first choice. Cline had wanted another Nelson song, “Funny How Time Slips Away,” but Billy Walker had already recorded it. Dick told NPR that she did not think too much of the song, and he and Bradley persuaded her to record it.

She had fought a hit like this once already. “Walkin’ After Midnight” reportedly made her cry, and on the phone with Four Star president Bill McCall, she was blunt about it.

“I don’t like it,” she told him, and then, “I hate it.” She told McCall “I still hate it” after he played it again.

The producers of Arthur Godfrey’s Talent Scouts insisted she sing it anyway on Jan. 21, 1957. The audience broke the applause meter, the label moved it to the A-side, and the song she hated went to No. 2 country and No. 12 pop as her first hit.

Patsy Cline Sang ‘Crazy’ on Crutches and Cut Her Vocal in a Single Take

On June 14, 1961, Cline and her brother Sam were in a head-on crash in Nashville. She went through the windshield and spent a month in the hospital with a broken wrist, a dislocated hip and a gash across her forehead, and her friend Dottie West later described picking glass out of her hair at the scene.

About two months later, it was time to make the record. She was still on crutches and could not hit the high notes because her broken ribs had not healed. Bradley’s brother Harold later recalled that she could not hold the notes out.

The first session, on Aug. 21, 1961, produced only the backing tracks. Bradley produced, with Floyd Cramer on piano and the Jordanaires on backing vocals, and Stoker remembered Cline telling Bradley exactly what she did not want.

“Look, I don’t want four male voices covering me up.”

Nelson has written that the record nearly failed for another reason. In Energy Follows Thought, his book about the stories behind his songs, he said it almost did not happen because Cline tried singing like him.

She came back on Sept. 15, 1961, and recorded her vocal in a single take. The woman who said there was no way she could sing it like that guy sang it like Patsy Cline, on crutches, one time through.

‘Crazy’ Became the Biggest of Patsy Cline’s Famous Songs

Patsy Cline’s famous songs include “Walkin’ After Midnight,” “I Fall to Pieces” and “Crazy,” and the one she did not want became the biggest of them. It peaked at No. 2 on Billboard’s country chart and reached the top 10 of the Hot 100, her only top-10 pop hit.

In 2003, “Crazy” was inducted into the Library of Congress National Recording Registry, and it has been called the most-played jukebox song in the U.S.

It changed things for the man who wrote it too. Nelson covered “Crazy” on his own debut album, …And Then I Wrote, in 1962, and the song helped launch his career.

Cline had little time with it. She died in a plane crash on March 5, 1963, at 30, less than a year and a half after the single came out.

Patsy Cline Hated Willie Nelson’s ‘Crazy,’ Then Recorded It on Crutches and Made It Her Signature Song
Music and books

Shop Willie Nelson

As an Amazon Associate, Country Thang Daily earns from qualifying purchases.

Nelson, the struggling writer whose song she did not want, looked back on what it meant to him in the same book.

“Crazy is as crazy does, and this particular ‘Crazy’ convinced me, at a time when I wasn’t a hundred percent sure of my writing talent, that I’d be crazy to stop writing.”

Patsy Cline Hated Willie Nelson’s ‘Crazy,’ Then Recorded It on Crutches and Made It Her Signature Song

Know someone who loves Patsy Cline?

Pass this story along to your friends and family on Facebook.

Share on Facebook

Latest Stories

Garth Brooks’ ‘Friends in Low Places’ Writer Says a $1,200 Bar Tab Probably Cost Him ‘$20 Million’

Earl Bud Lee was at lunch with friends in Nashville when the check came, and he did not have the money to cover it. As Ace Collins told the story ...

Tanya Tucker Called Glen Campbell Her ‘Greatest Love’ Years After Their Tabloid Romance

Glen Campbell had his arm around Tanya Tucker on the cover of People on June 30, 1980. He was 44 and she was 21, and the headline called them “the ...

Who Really Wrote ‘Ring of Fire’? June Carter’s Song Had a Life Before Johnny Cash Made It a Classic

Anita Carter needed a song, and she called from the studio to say so. Her sister June had an idea, taken from a book of poems that belonged to their ...

Vince Gill Sang ‘Go Rest High on That Mountain’ for John Anderson on the Opry Stage Anderson Helped Build

John Anderson was on the Grand Ole Opry’s schedule for Sunday, Nov. 8. He died on Oct. 21, and when that Sunday came, Vince Gill stood on the Opry stage ...

Pam Tillis Stands Up for Sammy Kershaw Over His CMA Red Carpet Denial and Warns ‘A Legacy Doesn’t Keep Itself’

Pam Tillis has spent most of her life making sure people remember that her daddy mattered. On Sunday, Nov. 8, she stood up and said the same thing about Sammy ...

Dale Earnhardt Jr. Shotguns a Beer After JR Motorsports’ Title, Then Fires Back at the ‘Shotgunning Beer Critics’

Dale Earnhardt Jr. shotgunned a beer in Victory Lane at Homestead-Miami Speedway, and the video spread fast. The last time he drank a beer at that track, it was the ...

Russell Dickerson Is Taking His First Break in 12 Years as Baby No. 3, a Girl, Is on the Way

Russell Dickerson wrote “God Gave Me A Girl” about his wife, Kailey, the mother of their two sons. On Wednesday, Nov. 4, that 2022 song played in the gender reveal ...

Were Conway Twitty and Loretta Lynn Lovers? Loretta Was Sitting With Her Husband When They Brought Conway In

Loretta Lynn was already at Cox Medical Center in Springfield, Missouri, on June 5, 1993, sitting with her gravely ill husband, Oliver “Doolittle” Lynn, when they brought Conway Twitty in. ...

CMA Says It’s ‘Deeply Sorry’ Over Sammy Kershaw’s Red Carpet Rejection, and Jake Owen Fires Back

Sammy Kershaw moved his tour dates around so he and his wife, Mendy, could go to the CMA Awards together. They booked flights and hotels, and he later wrote that ...

Ella Langley Reveals Beyoncé and Cody Johnson Had ‘Speaking Terms’ on Hold Before She Felt ‘Worth Enough’ for It

Ella Langley watched one song get pitched all over Nashville to other artists before she asked for it, and while opening for Morgan Wallen at Soldier Field in Chicago, she ...