Celebrate the Heart of Country, Americana, and Roots Music!

Drop Us A Line, Y'all

Y'all interested in advertising, partnering up, contributing stories, joining our team, or just got a question? Well, don't be shy, drop us a line!

Follow Us

The Song Carl Dean Warned Dolly Parton Not to Sing and Why She Did It Anyway

Carl Dean warned Dolly Parton not to cover Stairway to Heaven, but she followed her instincts and recorded it anyway, making it her own.
by
  • Riley is a Senior Country Music Journalist for Country Thang Daily, known for her engaging storytelling and insightful coverage of the genre.
  • Before joining Country Thang Daily, Riley developed her expertise at Billboard and People magazine, focusing on feature stories and music reviews.
  • Riley has a Bachelor of Arts in Journalism from Belmont University, with a minor in Cultural Studies.

Dolly Parton has always trusted her instincts. Whether she turned down Elvis Presley’s request to record “I Will Always Love You,” built her own empire with Dollywood, or jumped into rock music at 77 years old, she has never let doubt hold her back. But even the most fearless artists have people whose opinions matter.

For Dolly, that person was Carl Dean, her husband of nearly 60 years. Though he rarely weighed in on her music, there was one song he warned her not to touch: “Stairway to Heaven.”

Of course, Dolly being Dolly, she did it anyway.

Carl Dean’s Warning About Stairway to Heaven

Despite being married to a country music icon, Carl Dean wasn’t a fan of the genre. Dolly Parton has often joked that it was his least favorite. His tastes leaned more toward rock, so when she told him in 2002 that she planned to record “Stairway to Heaven,” he strongly opposed it.

“He said, ‘I don’t think you should do that,’ and I said, ‘Why?’ And he said, ‘Because it’s a legend. It’s a classic,'” Dolly recalled while promoting her 2023 album Rockstar.

“Stairway to Heaven” wasn’t just another song to Carl—it was one of rock’s most sacred anthems. He was worried that Dolly’s version wouldn’t sit well with fans who viewed it as untouchable. And in typical Carl fashion, he didn’t just stop at a simple warning. With his signature dry humor, he quipped, “Are you sure that’s ‘Stairway to Heaven’ or stairwell to hell?”

Dolly, however, had already made up her mind. Instead of a straight rock cover, she transformed “Stairway to Heaven” into a bluegrass ballad with a gospel-inspired arrangement. It was a bold choice, blending her Appalachian roots with one of the most famous rock songs of all time.

Carl, however, wasn’t convinced. When he finally heard the finished version, his reaction was lukewarm. “It’s okay,” he admitted—about as close to praise as he was willing to give. But his hesitation didn’t stop Dolly from pushing forward.

A Second Take for Rockstar

Two decades later, Dolly again found herself drawn to “Stairway to Heaven.” This time, she wasn’t just covering one rock song but making an entire rock album. Rockstar, released in 2023, was her way of proving that she could take on the genre she had been inducted into with the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame the year before.

However, unlike her 2002 version, Dolly stayed true to the original arrangement this time. She wanted to show the world—and Carl—that she could do justice to the song in its classic form.

RELATED: The Seven Songs Dolly Parton Wrote For Carl Dean And The Stories Behind Them

And Carl? This time, he gave his stamp of approval.

“He loved the new version because I stayed true to it,” Dolly revealed.

It was a rare moment when Carl changed his mind. The man who once warned her against touching “Stairway to Heaven” had to admit she got it right in the end. And if there’s one thing Dolly Parton has done her whole career, it’s proving that trusting her instincts always pays off—even when the person she loves most tells her otherwise.

Give it a listen and decide for yourself—did Dolly do “Stairway to Heaven” justice, just like Carl eventually thought?

Latest Stories

Allie Colleen performs on stage with a big smile and acoustic guitar, showing confidence and independence as she builds her music career on her own terms—far from her father Garth Brooks’ shadow.

Garth Brooks’ Daughter Says She Doesn’t Represent Him and Wants No Part of His Shadow

In a world where name-dropping can open every door in Nashville, Allie Colleen is out here trying to slam it shut. The 28-year-old country artist and youngest daughter of Garth ...

Blake Shelton and Miranda Lambert Moved On, But Did They Ever Make Amends?

Country music fans watched their fairytale unfold like a damn movie until the credits rolled too soon, and the lights came up on something way messier. Blake Shelton and Miranda ...

Gwen Stefani smiles at Blake Shelton on the red carpet of the Academy of Country Music Awards—despite new song lyrics fueling speculation about trouble in their marriage.

Gwen Stefani’s New Song Is Stirring Talk of Marriage Trouble With Blake Shelton and It’s Not Just the Lyrics

It doesn’t take much to set the rumor mill spinning, but Gwen Stefani just handed it a full tank of gas and a match. Her new single “Still Gonna Love ...

Nicole Kidman and Keith Urban smile on the red carpet at the Screen Actors Guild Awards, showing off their unshakable bond—even if a professional collaboration isn’t on the table.

Nicole Kidman Reveals Disappointing News About Keith Urban and Why They Won’t Work Together

Hollywood’s favorite Aussie power couple just crushed a longtime fan dream with one word. Nicole Kidman and Keith Urban may have the kind of private fairy tale that gives tabloid ...

Cody Johnson performs at an outdoor concert in front of an American flag, shown here during a previous show, before he paused his Tailgate N Tallboys set to address anti-Trump protests and lead the crowd in a "God Bless America" sing-along.

Cody Johnson Blasts Anti-Trump Protests and His Crowd Responds With a “God Bless America” Sing-Along

Cody Johnson doesn’t tiptoe. He stomps. During his June 14 stop at the Tailgate N Tallboys festival in Bloomington, Illinois, CoJo grabbed the mic, hit pause on the hits, and ...

HARDY performing live onstage in the U.S., shown here during a past show, ahead of canceling the European leg of his Jim Bob World Tour to prioritize family and crew.

HARDY Cancels European Leg of Jim Bob World Tour Ahead of First-Ever Headlining Dates

The long-awaited European run for HARDY’s Jim Bob World Tour just hit the brakes, and fans across the pond are understandably bummed. On the morning of June 16, HARDY dropped ...

Billy Ray Cyrus stands on the red carpet in a black leather jacket and sunglasses, unintentionally becoming the center of family drama after Trace Cyrus called him out online.

Trace Cyrus Blasts Billy Ray for Skipping Grandma’s Funeral to Chase Fame and It’s About as Ugly as It Gets

When your son calls you “the l𝐚mest man to ever walk planet earth,” it’s safe to say things have gone past the point of no return. Trace Cyrus is not ...

Holly Dunn performs passionately under soft stage lights with her guitar in hand, capturing the emotion behind her heartfelt classic “Daddy’s Hands.”

Holly Dunn Wrote “Daddy’s Hands” for Her Dad and Somehow Spoke for an Entire Generation

This is the kind of song that makes grown men stare out the truck window in silence and pretend it’s just the pollen getting to them. When Holly Dunn wrote ...

Oliver Anthony belts out raw heartbreak in a dimly lit studio session, his face scrunched in pain, strumming a resonator guitar with the kind of fury only divorce can fuel.

Oliver Anthony Poured His Divorce Hell Into “Scornful Woman” and It’s Flat-Out Devastating

You can smell the smoke coming off this one before the first note even hits. Oliver Anthony isn’t one for PR gloss or neatly packaged pain. He’s raw, gravel-throated, and ...

Brad Paisley strums his guitar under a spotlight—looking like he’s about to sing the song that breaks every stepdad’s heart wide open. Not the original performance, but you can feel the same lump in your throat.

Brad Paisley’s “He Didn’t Have to Be” Is the Ultimate Tribute to Men Who Chose to Be Dad

It’s the kind of song that sneaks up on you, then hits like a freight train made of soft memories and old regrets. Before Brad Paisley was co-hosting the CMAs ...