Right before Mary Chapin Carpenter walked onto the stage at the 1990 CMA Awards, she heard a man say something about her career.
“Right before I went out, I heard him say, ‘That was a nice career you had going there, Carpenter!’ When the audience stood and applauded, I was just flabbergasted,” she later told Engine 145.
Carpenter was not nominated in a single category that year, and she was far from the biggest name on the show. George Strait won Entertainer of the Year, and Garth Brooks took home the Horizon Award. Instead of promoting a track from her new album, she used her slot to sing an unreleased song called “Opening Act.”
It took a shot at the headliner she was opening for, a “jackass” in tight jeans and a hat.
“This is my career and I’m paying my dues/And if I ever get rich and famous I guess I’ll be a jackass, too/Till then, you don’t know me/I’m the opening act,” she sang.
The room gave her a standing ovation. More than 35 years later, fans still wonder who the jackass was, and the name most people land on is Dwight Yoakam.
Mary Chapin Carpenter First Said No. Tammy Wynette Held Her Hand.
Mary Chapin Carpenter was a genuine outsider when she sang it. She was born and raised in Princeton, New Jersey, came up through the folk scene around Washington, D.C., and signed with Columbia Records in the late 1980s after working with guitarist John Jennings. She never officially lived in Nashville.
Country Universe called the performance a risky move for a little-known new artist taking a stab at the industry that controlled her career.
The push to sing it came from the show. CMA Awards producers wanted “Opening Act,” and her first answer was an immediate no. She thought of it as a novelty number, and she worried it would lose some of its bite, because the version she played live was dirtier. The song was toned down for television, and in the end she decided it was a special opportunity.
Back in 1990, she put it even more plainly.
“Over my dead body would I have thought to do THAT song.”
Not everyone at the CMA was glad she did. According to Genius, CMA officials were horrified by the song and tried to organize a boycott of Carpenter, even appealing to Reba McEntire, and the effort failed.
One artist in the seats heard it another way. Carpenter told the Washington Business Journal that she was sitting next to Tammy Wynette, who held her hand and told her about a man who had treated her like dirt years earlier, when Tammy was just starting out.
“That’s when it really hit me. You could be a nobody like me or be Tammy Wynette, and you could relate to that song. That’s why it went over,” Carpenter said.
A legend and a newcomer heard the same story in one song.
Mary Chapin Carpenter Has Never Said Whether Dwight Yoakam Was the Jackass
Carpenter was touring with Dwight Yoakam when she wrote “Opening Act,” and he has long been the widely assumed target. Carpenter herself has never publicly confirmed who the jackass is, and she has described the song as coming from an unpleasant true story, or a composite of unpleasant experiences on the road.
She has also said that if the song had been about one person in particular, the whole audience would not have related to it. In her view, it went over because it is a universal experience. She has said more than once that incidents like that are the exception and not the rule, and that most of the time people are very nice to you.
The strongest argument against the Yoakam theory sits in her own catalog. Less than two years later, she namechecked him in a flattering, flirtatious way in “I Feel Lucky,” which suggests he may not have been the target after all.
RELATED: 8 Facts About Mary Chapin Carpenter That You Want To Know
The career that man joked about kept right on going. She won the ACM’s Top New Female Vocalist award in 1990, and two years after “Opening Act,” the CMA named her Female Vocalist of the Year, the first of back-to-back wins.
Her 1992 album Come On Come On became the biggest of her career, selling over two million copies on singles like “I Feel Lucky” and “Passionate Kisses,” and “I Feel Lucky” was nominated for CMA Single of the Year. “Down at the Twist and Shout,” from her 1990 album Shooting Straight in the Dark, won a Grammy in 1992, one of five she has won.
She has sold over 17 million records, and in 2012 she was inducted into the Nashville Songwriters Hall of Fame.
The newcomer who told a CMA crowd they did not know her was their Female Vocalist of the Year two years later, singing Dwight Yoakam’s name with a wink in “I Feel Lucky.” Mary Chapin Carpenter has still never publicly confirmed who the jackass in “Opening Act” was, or whether he was one man at all.
Know someone who loves Mary Chapin Carpenter?
Pass this story along to your friends and family on Facebook.