The 1961 hit “I Fall to Pieces” may not have been an easy success for Patsy Cline, but it turned out to be an enduring hit that forever cemented her place not just in country but also in pop.
Cline enjoyed several major hits in her short-lived eight-year recording career, including the first of her only two number-ones, “I Fall to Pieces.” The track was written by songwriting legends Hank Cochran and Harlan Howard and produced by Owen Bradley under Decca Records. But Cline wasn’t the first choice for this song. Bradley first pitched it to Brenda Lee and to Roy Drusky, who both rejected it.
Even Cline, who personally requested to cut it, wasn’t actually too fond of the song when she did her first recording in November 1960. In a 2015 Rolling Stone article, Stephen L. Betts noted that the singer gave the Jordainers, who served as her backup vocals, an icy reception because she was worried that their deep baritone voice would drown her rich contralto. She also wasn’t a fan of the instrumentation laid out for the song, the so-called “Nashville sound,” as she found it unsuitable for her singing style.
But it all worked out. According to Howard, “Once Patsy got into the groove, she just caressed those lyrics and that melody so tenderly that it was just like satin…Bradley said, ‘That’s the one.’”
The track scored Cline her first number one country record, albeit a very slow ascension, and earned her a crossover hit, popping off the pop charts at Top 15. It also reached the Adult Contemporary chart, peaking at the Top 10.
For You
Meaning Behind the Song
“I Fall to Pieces” was first released as a single in January 1961 and was rereleased in November on Showcase, the second of her three full-length albums.
The song is a bittersweet ballad, capturing unrequited love from the perspective of a woman who couldn’t fathom the fact that she and her lover are no longer together.
She tries her best to move on with her life and find someone new —like he wanted her to do — but all of her attempts end up in vain. She could never forget them. Each time she did, all it would take was the sound of his name, and she would crumble.
Over the years, many have covered this song, including Dottie West in 1964, Diana Trask in 1969, and a duet by Aaron Neville and Trisha Yearwood in 1994. But none could deliver the same gravitas Cline did.
Listen for yourself. Here’s Patsy Cline’s heartwrenching tune, “I Fall to Pieces.” Make sure to check out other Patsy Cline songs. They’re worth your while.
