Long before there was a lawsuit, there was a hat.
Adam LaRoche made an E3 hat as a novelty, Luke Bryan wore it, and for years Bryan and Jason Aldean joked about bringing E3 Chophouse to Nashville.
LaRoche, the former MLB player, opened the first E3 Chophouse in Steamboat Springs, Colorado, in 2013 with his brothers Jeff and Andy. When the Nashville restaurant was announced in 2019, he told the story himself.
RELATED: Jason Aldean’s Tupelo Show Just Became the Highest-Grossing Concert in the City’s History
“Jason & Luke jokingly talked for years about opening an E3 Chophouse in Nashville, and over time those talks became more serious. … It’s come a long way from Luke wearing the E3 hat I made as a novelty many years ago, and we are humbled and excited to bring the restaurant to Music City.”
Seven years later, the steakhouse in Hillsboro Village is closed, and Bryan and Aldean are fighting a $1.4 million lawsuit over it, denying they are responsible for the damages the landlord is seeking. According to court documents obtained by TMZ, the two stars filed separate but nearly identical responses, and both are asking the court to reject the landlord’s claims.
E3 Chophouse Closed in February, and the Landlord Wants the Men Who Guaranteed Its Lease to Pay
The deal goes back to 2018, when Outlaws, LLC signed a 10-year lease that was set to run through Aug. 31, 2029. The Nashville E3 Chophouse opened at 1628 21st Ave. South, in Hillsboro Village, in 2019.
Bryan, Aldean and LaRoche personally guaranteed that lease, and that promise is why landlord Village 21 Investment Partners wants to hold the three of them responsible.
The lawsuit says rent for January and February 2026 went unpaid. In its complaint, filed in Davidson County Circuit Court, the landlord says the restaurant stopped paying the monthly rent and closed abruptly. The lawsuit says operations ceased on Feb. 19, and Whiskey Riff reports the doors shut after Valentine’s Day weekend.
RELATED: Luke Bryan and Blake Shelton Reportedly Fed Up With Morgan Wallen’s Wild Behavior
The restaurant called it a temporary pause in a post on social media.
“We’re temporarily pausing operations as we evaluate what Nashville needs next,” the post said.
When the case reached a damages hearing, no representative for the restaurant’s operating company attended, and a default judgment of $1,427,135.54 was entered against that company. In June, the landlord moved to amend the lawsuit and add Bryan, Aldean and LaRoche as defendants.
That personal guarantee is the whole case now.
Bryan and Aldean Say Their Guarantee Puts the Bill at About $59,000
The two stars and LaRoche read that promise very differently. In a motion for summary judgment, the three argue the landlord’s reading of the guaranty is wrong and that they owe far less than $1.4 million.
By their account, the guarantees covered rent only for the first five years of the lease. After that, they say, the guarantees covered only the remaining construction allowance.
“The formula provided by the guaranty cap requires simple arithmetic,” their attorneys wrote in an October court filing reviewed by Billboard.
Their arithmetic puts the potential liability at about $59,000 in all, or $19,585.60 for each of them. Set next to the landlord’s figure of more than $1.4 million, that leaves a gap of well over a million dollars.
RELATED: Why Some Country Fans Can’t Stand Luke Bryan and Others Say He Saved the Genre
Shop Luke Bryan
- #1’s Volume 2VinylWith “Huntin’, Fishin’ and Lovin’ Every Day” and “Most People Are Good”See it on Amazon
- SignsVinylSee it on Amazon
As an Amazon Associate, Country Thang Daily earns from qualifying purchases.
The singers’ responses go further. They call the landlord’s alleged damages “speculative, uncertain, and not recoverable” under their lease guarantee, and they claim the landlord failed to take proper steps to minimize its losses.
When E3 Chophouse came to Nashville, Bryan, Aldean and LaRoche personally guaranteed its lease. The case is scheduled for a hearing in January, and the question is whether those guarantees are worth $19,585.60 apiece or more than $1.4 million.
Know someone who loves Luke Bryan?
Pass this story along to your friends and family on Facebook.